The Mitochondrial-CoQ10 PWS Connection?
William V. Judy. Ph.D. Janet S. Judy, RN
COENZYME Q10 (Ubiquinone)
Coenzyme
Q10 (CoQ10) is a relatively new molecule in science. It was
discovered in 1957 at the Enzyme Research Center at the University
of Wisconsin It was isolated from beef heart mitochondria by
Fredrick Crane It was soon found to be in all
cell membranes and all cell organelle membranes, in all species in
the animal and plant kingdoms, In man, it is produced in all cells
in the first two decades of life and decreases gradually thereafter.
It is in most of the food that we eat especially meat protein and
dark green leafy vegetables. It is found in beans, peas, and large
nuts, but not in small grains. Formula and milk have no CoQ10, but
do have the nutritional substrates required for CoQ10 synthesis.
Processing and cooking foods reduces the CoQ10 content.
C0Q10 has five known functions in the body:
1. Responsible for 95% of
the energy produced in the body.
2. Potent intracellular antioxidant.
3. Prevents atherosclerosis
4. Prevents abnormal protein synthesis and thus age related
degenerative diseases.
5. Stabilizes all cell membranes.
Its role in energy synthesis
was part of a Nobel Prize awarded in 1978 to Sir Peter Mitchell.
CoQ10 is a large molecule, soluble only in lipids, thus poorly
absorbed In the body. Dry powder CoQ10 is poorly absorbed, not only
because of its large size but also because it will not dissolve in
lipids at body temperature. Both the dry powder CoQ10 and the
crystalline CoQ10 in an oil base are poorly absorbed. The new Iiquid
CoQ10 softgel form has a 900% greater absorption than these do. It
is the form currently being used in children with PWS.

MITOCHONDRIA-ENERGY PRODUCING ORGANELLES
FOUND IN ALL LIVING CELLS
Energy is strictly a
mitochondrial function. Mitochondria are found in all
living cells. They are small bean-shaped
structures with outer and inner membranes. Five percent of the total
body energy is produced In the breakdown of food substances to NADH,
which occurs in the outer membrane of the mitochondria. The inner
membrane is the location for Complexes I, II, and III in the
synthesis of energy. The remaining ninety-five percent of energy is
produced here in the presence of oxygen. This occurs when NADH (from
the outer membrane) is converted to energy (ATP) through electron
transfer. CoQ10 and Cytochrome C are the mediators for electron
transfer through Complex II and III. Of these three intermediates (NADH,
CoQ10, and Cytochrome C),
CoQ10 is the only one found to be deficient in patients with low
energy syndromes, including PWS.
Multiple genetic and non-genetic mitochondrial disorders have been
described. In many of these clinical conditions, low CoQ10 content
has been found in the body.
Deficiencies of CoQ10 result in reduced energy synthesis.
Under these conditions, the mitochondria show morphological changes
in size, shape and location. They dry up to raisin-like organelles
and are found clumped together rather than being distributed evenly
throughout the cell. This results in clinical conditions that effect
infants, children, and adults. Included in these are PWS, muscular
dystrophy, multiple sclerosis, Huntington's Chorea,
chronic fatigue
syndrome, Parkinson's disease, hyperthyroid disease, heart failure,
some forms of cancer, and effects of excessive drug therapy with
certain pharmaceuticals.
DNA is found in all mitochondria. It is responsible for reproduction
of mitochondria, which occurs under conditions of increased cell
activity such as exercise and training. Trained individuals have
higher numbers and greater distributions of mitochondria in skeletal
muscle compared to non-trained individuals. Under conditions of
muscle dysfunction (such as hypotonia and atrophy) the mitochondria
have been shown to be abnormal and non-functional. In the case of
CoQ10 deficiencies, this is known to occur in adults when blood
levels are reduced to 0.55ug/ml or less.
CoQ10 supplementation in
individuals with known deficiencies significantly increases
mitochondrial energy synthesis and results in an improved clinical
condition and quality of life.

LOW
ENERGY SYNDROME
Low energy syndromes have
been linked to poor nutrition, digestive disorders, endocrine
disorders, Vitamin B deficiencies, mitochondrial dysfunction, age
and CoQ10 deficiency.
CoQ10 deficiency occurs with
age. This is probably due to two things, either a dietary
deficiency in the substrates required to make CoQ10 or an overall
dysfunction of the biochemical mechanisms responsible for CoQ10
synthesis. It is uncommon for children and young adults to be
deficient in CoQ10. In infants with PWS, there appears to be an
inability of the body to produce and/or utilize CoQ10. Without
adequate CoQ10, energy synthesis in the inner membrane of the
mitochondria is limited. Thus, in children with PWS who have CoQ10
deficiency and normal mitochondria,
CoQ10 supplementation should
enhance energy synthesis and therefore metabolic activity in all
body systems. If the mitochondrial mechanism is undeveloped
or nonfunctional, then CoQ10 supplementation may have limited
effects unless the mitochondrial function can be revived.
We have one example of the benefits of CoQ10 supplementation in a
child with PWS who has both a chromosome 15 abnormality and a
Complex II and II involvement. This child, for the first six months
of life, did not cry nor move and was fed via a NG tube. Within
three days of starting CoQ10 supplementation, the child began to
develop sucking reflexes and move arms, hands, legs, and feet. With
continued CoQ10 supplementation, crawling, standing and walking
occurred between eight and twelve months. Today after three years of
CoQ10 supplementation, in the absence of any nutritional, hormonal
or drug intervention this child has normal physical and mental
development. Speech patterns, physical skills, and cognitive
functions are in the normal range for the age level.

THE
MITOCHONDRIA-LOW ENERGY-CoQ10 STORY
Energy is required for all
the body systems to function, including the synthesis of the
steroids, hormones, enzymes, and coenzymes required for muscle
energetics, physical and mental growth, and development of sex
characteristics. Without energy, the caloric content of food cannot
be converted to useful energy and thus stored as fat and hunger
persists. Hence it may be possible that multiple symptoms of PWS are
related to an endogenous CoQ10 deficiency or to abnormal
mitochondrial complexes in the energy synthesis mechanism. Some of
the symptoms include: muscle hypotonia, low metabolic rate,
hypothermia, poor growth pattern, mental retardation and delayed
speech development, hypogonadism, hypopigmentation, osteoporosis,
hyperphagia, obesity, and diabetes (Type II).
To date, we know much more about PWS than we did three decades ago.
Most of this is in the field of genetics. No specific biochemical
marker (hormone or enzyme) has been found until recently. No widely
accepted treatment for this condition has been formulated except for
the use of growth hormone to stimulate growth and calorie
restriction to prevent obesity. Recently, we have found below normal
plasma CoQ10 levels in a majority (75%) of children with PWS tested
between the ages of two months and six years. Whether this is a
result of the genetic abnormality or is a separate entity causing
the low energy characteristics in these children is unknown. The
symptoms of PWS certainly point to a CoQ10 deficiency and thus an
abnormal mitochondrial energy synthesis mechanism.
The statement "use it or
lose it" pertains to the mitochondria. Without adequate numbers of
functioning mitochondria or CoQ10, energy synthesis is significantly
reduced. Even slight deficiencies of plasma CoQ10 can result
in mitochondrial dysfunction because six to eight times more
molecules of CoQ10 are required than Cytochrome C and fifty times
more than NADH dehydrogenase. When mitochondria are not stimulated
by a sufficient amount of CoQ10, they shrivel, migrate and clump in
one area of the cell. This renders the mitochondria virtually
useless. This can happen even in the presence of adequate CoQ10 when
such is not properly utilized Mitochondria can be rejuvenated by a
combined therapy of exercise and increasing plasma CoQ10 levels
above normal.
In only one child who has had CoQ10 supplementation for an extended
interval can possible answers for others be given to the
mitochondria-low energy story. So, is CoQ10 one of the keys required
to unlock the unknown management possibilities of PWS? To date, this
is also unknown. One positive example is not adequate proof. For
this reason, SIBR, Inc. has proposed to the Prader-Willi Syndrome
Association (USA), secured funding, and established the first
PWS-CoQ10 study program. Today we have only questions, tomorrow
let's hope we have some answers.